This would serve as a best Christmas gift for both of you to hangout together on the auspicious occasion.
Now this may sound as more common but chocolate/flowers are a safe game to play.
And no, you cannot just get him a box of boring chocolates. has some great cocktails that aren't impossible to make.2. At a play, you can connect over how much you appreciate the arts — a little bit of post-show dramatic criticism is basically mental foreplay. Give him your favorite book, or one that you could read together and then talk about it. Look for a mug that's specific to the person you're dating — i.e.: a mug that says, "I'm The Top Bitch In Cat Town," may not bode well for a dude. He told you when you first started messaging online that he music, but you noticed that he's still using the crappy headphones that came with his phone.
Every one of us is fond of some kind of music, movies or television shows.
So get a step further and gift your date some of his/her favorite ones.
Without getting too much into mess of thinking what to gift and what not, simply take him/her to another date.
Candles, snacks, light music and lovely ambience are all you need for a perfect Christmas evening to be like.
Like get the first date picture of you two engraved on the mug etc.